+- Thay - Realm of the Red Wizards (https://thaypw.com)
+-- Forum: Meta (https://thaypw.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: The Tavern (https://thaypw.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=10)
+---- Forum: [Archived - The Tavern] (https://thaypw.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=63)
+---- Thread: HTF - Benefits and Losses (/showthread.php?tid=2837)
RE: HTF - Benefits and Losses - TheShadowEntity - 04-14-2015
Well, If its just 1-3 hp when my pc eats or drinks and nothing more at all then i may be better off turning it off. I had always assumed that there was some tangible advantage (Extra xp/rep/somthing) because the system is so demanding and carries the risk of killing a pc, especially because i tend to require long afk periods some times.
Now granted that's just MY personal situation. But i am glad to be finding this stuff out. Still... Somehow i feel like there's this little voice inside me saying "Don't turn off HTF"..
Guess its just cause i am so used to it from multiple servers now XD
RE: HTF - Benefits and Losses - Balanor - 04-14-2015
Rich food also has a chance to cure disease when eaten. Rich drink has the chance to neutralize poison. Hit Points gained should be up to 8 with rich food and 6 with a rich drink. Keep in mind that if someone has the room and is pretty hungry or thirsty, this could heal a number of hit points if several items are eaten/drank in succession. No healing occurs if the PC is fully satiated with whatever they are trying to consump (feed or drink). I'll double-check that sometime to see if that's the case or if it needs to be adjusted to do so.
I personally love HTF, and initially made it a requirement. But after enough...well...you know....that changed. So I do want to make sure that those who are using it get benefits that others do not. And hopefully, with many Poison (and Disease) effects becoming permanent until cured at a healer, some of this system's benefits will become even more attractive.
RE: HTF - Benefits and Losses - Bertram Anders - 04-14-2015
So the real question now then is what classifies as rich food and drink.
RE: HTF - Benefits and Losses - Balanor - 04-14-2015
Well...how about we do this - below is the list of all the food and drink (minus alchohol - sorry LooseWilly) in Thay. How about anyone interested go through them and make your recommendations as to what should be classified as High food/drink. If you want to go even further, feel free to do normal and poor food/drink as well. For some that may be questionable as to why , I'd also appreciate any brief explanation as to why you think it is high/normal/poor. I may make revisions based on consensus if something is currently classified in a category the majority of you feel it should not be.
Berries
Biscuit
Bowl of Gruel
Bowl of Stew
Burned Fish
Burned Meat
Cheese
Cracker
Egg
Fig
Fresh Bass
Fresh Bear
Fresh Beef
Fresh Chicken
Fresh Cod
Fresh Meat
Fresh Pike
Fresh Pork
Fresh Trout
Fresh Tuna
Fresh Venison
Goblet of Wine
Herbal Cracker
Herbal Thirst Quencher
Juice
Lembas Bread
Loaf of Bread
Milk*
Mushroom
Nuts
Onion
Pie
Roast Bear
Roast Beef
Roast Chicken
Roast Fish
Roast Meat
Roast Pork
Roast Venison
Roasted Nuts
Smoked Sausage
Spring Water
*Right now, Milk has the unique distinction as being classified as both food and drink. If you feel this should change, or if others should be classified as both food/drink, state your reasons.
RE: HTF - Benefits and Losses - Animayhem - 04-14-2015
Milk should be kept as both. In the real world, some medications labels state, take with food or milk.
Cheese, figs, eggs are healthy choice snacks in real life and should be rich foods. Roasted meats are protien source so I would also concider those rich as well as the stew. The same with the raw meat and fish for those who eat them raw, that is if they can be. Ie, gnolls, lycans, shifters in animal forms. Herbal thirst quencher and juice should be high for the liquid side.
For those who do not eat meat additonal rich foods could include nuts and berries.
RE: HTF - Benefits and Losses - LifeLikeSage - 04-14-2015
Maybe you could set certain foods to be high quality to different races? Like half-orcs benefiting from a bowl of gruel while others not?
RE: HTF - Benefits and Losses - Hellstrom - 04-14-2015
My thoughts...
Rich - these foods offer many calories, or a variety of vitamins and protein
Bowl of Stew
Bowl of Vegetable Stew*
Herbal Thirst Quencher
Lembas Bread
Roast Bear
Roast Beef
Roast Chicken
Roast Fish
Roast Pork
Roast Venison
Normal - nutritious, but not quite as much as the foods above
Milk*
Berries
Cheese
Egg
Fig
Fresh Bass (chance of disease for eating anything raw?)
Fresh Bear
Fresh Beef
Fresh Chicken
Fresh Cod
Fresh Pike
Fresh Pork
Fresh Trout
Fresh Tuna
Fresh Venison
Herbal Cracker
Juice
Loaf of Bread
Nuts
Pie
Spring Water
Smoked Sausage
Roasted Nuts
Poor - lacking in many nutrients or are made from poor ingredients
Biscuit
Bowl of Gruel
Burned Fish
Burned Meat
Cracker
Fresh Meat (Rat?)
Goblet of Wine
Mushroom
Onion
Roast Meat (Rat?)
I put relatively few vegetarian things in the Rich category. It's certainly healthy to eat salad & veggies, but in our society that generally means "things that help you lose weight or not get fat". It takes a lot of salad to power a person who's fighting, carrying 300#, and/or running in terror.
*New to give the vegetarians some options
RE: HTF - Benefits and Losses - TheShadowEntity - 04-15-2015
See... The reason i wanted to know was because it carries a pretty big risk of dyeing of thirst hunger in comparison to the tiny benefits it currently offers.
HTF had killed me twice since i joined here... It has never saved me once.. that's sorta a bad sign for the usefulness of the system. So much so that i actually turned it off on one of my pc's just a few hours ago. The benefits simply are not worth it. This is my reasoning summed up.
Good - HTF
1. Gives a tiny amount of hp when you eat / drink
Bad - HTF
1. High risk of dyeing if you need to go afk because the counter keeps ticking even in afk mode. (this alone killed me once)
2. Not cost effective in comparison to healing supplies . (i can get more HP and uses by buying a cheap bandage for around the same amount)
3. Food costs money... Its a constant drain on your coin no matter what.
4. Food & Drink weigh you down.
RE: HTF - Benefits and Losses - Bertram Anders - 04-15-2015
(04-14-2015, 11:27 AM)Thayan Wrote: Rich food also has a chance to cure disease when eaten. Rich drink has the chance to neutralize poison. Hit Points gained should be up to 8 with rich food and 6 with a rich drink.
RE: HTF - Benefits and Losses - Animayhem - 04-15-2015
Well, healing is not just bandages but also how much skill points you put into it. If you are playing a character with low skill points in healing, food and drink can stablize and get you up to a level by which you can use a bandage.
Its a balance. Charatcters with HTF off compensate by loading up on bandages and healing potions which on average more costly than food and drink.